patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Utility Companies Accountable Under Proposed Bill

State Sen. Kevin O'Toole wants PSE&G, JCP&L and others to improve response times during emergency situations.

 

A North Jersey state senator is proposing legislation to cut down on the long lines at gas stations and ensure the safety of residents during emergencies.

State Sen. Kevin O’Toole (R-Cedar Grove) is co-sponsoring the New Jersey Residents Power Protection Act. The legislation would hold utility companies accountable for their response times during emergencies. It would also require gas stations and other facilities to have generators on hand to ensure residents have access to power and gasoline during emergencies situations.

“It was apocalyptic in North Jersey in the days following Hurricane Sandy,” O’Toole said. “Sometimes, there was no evidence of any activity by the power companies at all.”

O’Toole spoke regularly with several North Jersey mayors, including Chris Vergano of Wayne and Paul Aronsohn of Ridgewood, about the lack of progress PSE&G, JCP&L and Orange and Rockland were making in restoring power to hundreds of thousands of North Jersey residents.

“He personally assisted the township in finding fuel supplies to keep the township in business so our Department of Public Works and fire trucks could respond to residents during the storm,” Wyckoff Mayor Chris DePhillips said. “He also worked hand-in-hand with me to apply strong pressure on both PSE&G and Orange & Rockland to get the necessary restoration crews into Wyckoff.”

PSE&G cut the power to the only overnight shelter in Ridgewood for eight hours Nov. 4.

Several mayors, including Vergano, and Aronsohn, publically criticized the power companies for their lack of preparedness and response to Sandy.

The RPPA would require assisted living facilities, firehouses and gas stations, among other facilities, to have emergency generators running during power outages.

New grocery stores, including smaller ones like Quick Chek, would be required to install a generator on their property. Small businesses could apply for a tax deduction for installing a generator.

“This will help utility companies in restoring power and clearing roadways with the relief that the critical need facilities are operating,” O’Toole said. “Vendors were delivering fuel to towns so their emergency vehicles could be fueled.”

The RPPA would require the state Board of Public Utilities to develop and enforce performance benchmarks for power companies.

Companies would be required to file a service reliability plan and an emergency communications strategic plan.

The bill would increase the civil penalties utility companies would pay for violating rules enforced by the BPU.

Penalties would increase from $100 a day to $25,000 for each violation up to $2 million. Penalties would go into a special fund. The BPU would use the funds to increase service quality and reliability.

Cracking Down on Price Gouging, Scam Artists

O’Toole is also sponsoring proposed legislation that would increase the penalty for burglary in a municipality where a state of emergency has been declared. The charge would be upgraded from a third-degree to a second-degree offense.

The legislation could be expanded to include trespassing and theft by deception to curb price gouging by gas stations. Two Newark gas stations were accused of price gouging in the aftermath of Sandy.

If expanded, the legislation would help stop illicit contractors from attempting to scam residents out of their money. These scam artists go door-to-door promising residents to fix their damaged homes. Once they receive their deposits they leave and don’t perform the work.

That bill is still being drafted and has not been introduced yet.

Related Topics: Hurricane Sandy and Senator Kevin O'Toole

Mike Domlija

8:24 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

If the senator really wants to make a difference, he should sign, sponsor and promote the petition to bury the power lines:
http://www.change.org/petitions/governor-chris-christie-bury-the-power-lines-in-new-jersey

Reply
Comment_arrow

n

10:36 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Underground lines are no guarantee of the prevention of black outs.

Comment_arrow

Mike Domlija

10:48 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

@n
There are no guarantees in life my friend, but if you read the petition, you will see that in places where power lines are underground, power outages are significantly reduced.

Comment_arrow

n

1:08 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

@Mike, You're correct about guarantees, but if a tree falls on a line by single family house, you may lose power on one house, but if a tree falls on a transformer(they are above ground), you will lose a whole development. Plus you have the added fun of flooding that can knock out underground power and also the added expense of maintenance & repair.

Comment_arrow

Tryclyde

1:19 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

We have a better chance of seeing a unicorn than have this petition do anything. The cost is FAR too high.

jp1

8:41 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

How much of an increase are you willing to pay to bury the power lines? Cost today is about $760,000 per mile.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mike Domlija

10:06 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Glad you brought up the cost issue, since this is the main stumbling block. Several states (unfortunately NJ is not one of them) have provided cost estimates to bury the lines in their states. In North Carolina, for example, the estimated cost is $41 billion. New Jersey's area is six times smaller, so the cost should be lower. For comparison, the total cost of Hurricane Sandy is estimated at $60 billion, most of it lost business due to power outages. Gov. Cuomo has asked for $30 billion in federal aid to repair the damage from the storm. Why not ask for another $10 billion to bury the lines on Long Island over the next 10 or 20 years? The same logic applies to NJ: this kind of capital project cannot be financed by property owners only.

Comment_arrow

Steve

10:51 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I don't think the cost is due to the size of the state but the number of miles that would be buried and in what kind of location they would be buried in. Comparing NJ to NC is like comparing an apple to an orange.

Comment_arrow

I am Spartacus

11:51 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Do you want to pay the cost to bury lines in every state that is at risk of getting hit by a big hurricane, blizzard, wind storm, ice storm or thunderstorm? The cost to do that is in the trillions and the only way the rest of the country will agree to pay for the cost of burying lines around here is if you are willing to help pay the cost to bury everyone else's lines.

Comment_arrow

Mike Domlija

12:38 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Good point, but the rest of the country is already paying through federal aid to NJ and NY. Last year they paid for Irene, this year for Sandy. Again, most of the cost they are paying for is for lost business due to power outages. Why not allocate some of the funds and start this infrastructure program, at least in the areas with high population densities and not prone to flooding? It does not necessarily mean that every line in every state will be buried, but it would be a good start.

zizi

8:50 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I would rather just auction off the huge trees that cause the problem and limit the kind of new trees that can be planted. Only small trees should be allowed to be planted near power lines. This will save money and lower our taxes.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kelly

9:32 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

How does it lower our taxes? Is it the town who is supposed to be trimming these trees? Just asking, I really don't know how it affects the taxes. Thanks.

Comment_arrow

n

10:40 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

@Kelly, In Bernards Twp, they only trim trees in the public right of way and they don't that very often as it is.

Todd J

8:57 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

The state should partner with big companies like Verizon, Cablevision, Comcast, Google Fiber, etc. to install their fiber-optic lines underground so they can offer services throughout the state and share in the cost of running the underground power lines.

Reply

Edward P. Campbell

9:55 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Try and remember, ultimately any fines, or other demands placed on the power companies, gas stations, or grocery stores end up being paid for 100% by us the consumer. To the best of my knowledge, power companies, gas stations, and grocery stores can’t print money. All they can do is collect it from us!

Reply
Comment_arrow

I am Spartacus

11:54 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

All taxes that businesses must pay get passed along to the customer. These politicians know that but they want to pretend that isn't the case and hope voters never pick up on the fact that they ultimately are the ones who pay those taxes through price increases. It is true w/ gas taxes, beer taxes, soda taxes, Obamacare taxes & taxes or fines levied against the utility companies.

Robert Pignatello

10:12 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

All these weeks later after the power went out we are now hearing from our state representatives about the restoration efforts. I heard and saw very little from them, as people as were struggling in the dark, to push the utilities companies to do better. Where is the Board of Public Utilities in all this who regulate them? Last year many of us lost power for a week. The state said they would hold the utilities more accountable. Well, they clearly did not. And it's not just north jersey. Look what the people of Long Island are going through and LIPA is under fire from the state and local government in new york. One of the ways to assess why things in government happen or don't is to "follow the money". When you do, in this case, you will see years of political contributions in the thousands of dollars from Jcpl and their parent company First Energy to political candidates and state legislators and political parties across the state and right here in north jersey. Including major contributions they made to political parties this year and last. This is why and how politics usually gets in the way of good government and the interests of the people.

Reply
Comment_arrow

n

10:45 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I would be more interested in seeing Kevin O’Toole push a bill limiting how much state senators get paid and increase the amount of money they contribute to their health & pension, like they did to the judges. What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

11:10 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Classic pandering!

Where was the Senator a few weeks ago when we needed support?

Senator Otoole is going to ask for your vote in 7 months (June 2013).

Remember where the State Legislative incumbents were when we needed them! I know they were not walking door-to-door with Joanie Walsh, Joe Bubba, Jr. and me calling the outages into the Governor’s Office and getting petitions signed to revoke JCP&L’s franchise.

I hope a few of the homeowners that share my outrage decide to run for elected office. I am considering it myself.

Comment_arrow

Jack Q

1:08 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Jackie,

Talk about classic pandering. When are Joe and Joanie going to ask for votes?

Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

8:19 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

What Joanie, Joe and I are asking for right now is an attorney that is willing to petition the state to revoke JCP&L's Wayne franchise.

Were Senator Otoole and Scott Rumana responding to allegations of unethical practice while the people of the 40th District needed them? The pandering politicians may have been preoccupied with saving their tails rather than paying attention to the lack of response JCP&L routinely demonstrates.

Rumana and Otoole are attorneys - let's see if they sue JCP&L for our economic loss. Let's see if they file a petition with the BPU to revoke JCP&L's franchise.

Are the campaign contributions more important than the people?

Comment_arrow

Mike S

10:30 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

@Jacqueline Pisatowski,

You, Joanie and Bubba Jr went out to "check on your neighbors" bc as you said you are considering running for office next year. Now THAT'S the definition of pandering!

Before saying they weren't around to help, did you try calling them? I did, and they were immediately on the phone with JCP&L to find out when JCP&L would come to my neighborhood and get my power on.

You go pander to your neighbors for votes, and I'll talk to those who can actually do something to help!

Sue Osnato

10:36 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I am devastated by the loss of all these magnificent trees. Our forests and landscapes have been changed forever. It is sad to drive around and see the carnage.

I don't think cutting down more or planting only small trees is the answer. Also, underground lines are not necessarily fail safe either. The power companies are supposed to maintain a clearance from their lines. To my knowledge after Irene came through certain town councils did push for this. The power companies need to be responsible on their end. In this area though there are so many trees. It seems an impossible task to keep them all clear of lines.

If you don't want trees, live in the city.

This was an unfortunate event. It was made worse by the lack of response to the inland areas. Who's fault that is, may lie across many hands.

I think requiring generators at certain facilities makes absolute sense. Our police department was without power. That makes no sense at all to me. Gas stations should always be able to pump gas. This also added to much of the angst experienced.

I also wholeheartedly support stricter penalties for those who break and enter for their own gain. These people are total low-lifes and should be treated as such.

Our part of Route 22 had many break-ins. This is inexcusable.

I live in Green Brook and there are many areas for correction so there is no next time.

Reply
Comment_arrow

n

10:57 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

@Sue O., It is a wasted bill. To requiring generators at certain facilities, will only increase costs back to either the consumer or tax payer. If your police chief didn't use his head and arrange to have a generator installed prior to this event, then he needs to step down and find someone who has commons sense.Increasing the penalties for B&E will not prevent the crime, which most are a crime of opportunity. Plus as in Bernards, they were tied up anyway either sitting a gas stations, downed wires, or closed roads, not patrolling.

Comment_arrow

I am Spartacus

11:48 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

It is prohibitively expensive to cut down all the trees. It is even more expensive to bury the lines. It is complete stupidity to replace a tree that was knocked down and took down power lines with another tree that will grow to 80 ft tall in a generation or two and knock out power lines in the future. The only way to mitigate the risk of power outages in the future is to not plant trees that will get real tall near power lines, prune or cut trees near lines more aggressively in the future and insist lines be buried in the future in areas where new development occurs.

Comment_arrow

stewart resmer

1:02 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

in my neighboothood it was a homeowmers tree that fell cutiing off power to the rest of us, there ar 16 tree trunks growing through the power lines on his lot alone!
I appreciate trees as much as anyone else, but seriously folks? get them away from power lines, period.
By the way? On this run of the power lines? We are already underground. It is ridiculous to require the rest of us to bear the expense of underground lines only to be fed by over head wires that are subject to tree falls in this example

Rock

10:43 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

The sad reality is that this will all largely be forgotten, similar to all of the storms -- and far more severe ones -- that have occured in the past.

Its all fresh in our minds now, and we are bustling with the 'fix this' and 'never again' energy -- but it will dissipate in the months to come.....

Until the next storm.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sue Osnato

10:49 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

It will be forgotten, only if we let it. I don't plan to let up on it at all. It only takes one voice from each town to be persistent on your town, county and state level. Go to meetings, make phone calls. Don't let our political leaders or the power companies forget. It doesn't take much time from your personal life to stay on top of it.

Comment_arrow

Rock

11:53 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Sue --
Admittedly an admirable goal.

And maybe this is the storm that does it...but if past history is any predictor of future results, you might be just yelling into the wind. Irene and the Halloween storm were only just last year.

Go back farther and the names are familiar but the details are sketchy for many of us: Gloria, Floyd, Isabel.

And one has to only do a cursory search of older large storms in the Northeast to come away with some pretty large storms that are largely forgotten.

RamseyDad

10:56 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

This is apparently the biggest storm to hit this area directly in the last hundred years. We've been relatively spoiled by our relative immunity to natural disasters. People and businesses need to make their own preparations for the most part. Expectations of retro-burying cables and wholesale tree removal are unrealistic. In the not too likely prospect of a repeat of of this scenario in the near future, a lot of the problem trees are already gone. People, businesses, and municipalities should learn some lessons from this event and act proactively and prudently and not expect somebody else to foot the bill...

Reply

Sir

11:11 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Lets have the 1% pay for it.

Reply

Ridgewooder

11:35 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I think that utility companies should ensure their applicable service is being delivered at all times.

Reply

BRER

12:16 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I think it is a great idea to mandate gas station have generators powerful enough to maintain service. I think to blame power companies without any specifics and details given the magnitude of Sandy's destructive forces is unreasonable. This is unprecedented so there is really no way to "reason" what is reasonable level of preparedness by the power companies. One thing for sure, though, something I have said repeatedly, is the strong need to cut down any trees that can potentially topple into power lines. Between being environmentally sensitive and dying of cold exposure due to lack of heat from power loss, the choice should be quite simple. We need to explore ways that can afford the town to clear all the trees. Sandy did a bunch for us already, the rest is on us!

Reply

Rock

12:29 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Some good points here.

Another thing to keep in mind is perspective. Over the last, say, 3 years how many days of power has an individual home lost? Maybe 18 days roughly (?) and thats at the high end.

Thats still a success rate of about 99.98%

How many billions do we want to really pay to get that number closer to 100% ?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kelly

1:35 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I'm am not saying we are average, and we were on the low end this time (3 days), but including Irene and Snowtober that adds up to ~14 days no power right there. Add the fact that the power goes out by me every 1.5-2 months (every time we have a strong thunderstorm) for anywhere from a couple hours to a day or so. I don't remember if it was 3 or 4 years ago that we had those April storms with high winds that took down trees everywhere and killed power for a few days. I don't know what it is like by anyone else, but in my neck of the woods (not even that wooded), I would say 18 days of no power in the past 3 years is not at the high end of things.

We got a notice after last year's outages that they would be coming around to trim the trees in our area. I was grateful since there is a tree on the road that has branches all around the lines, but they never came. I can only assume they aren't going to anytime soon either.

Kommon Sense

12:36 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I think that this entire episode boils down to lack of individual preparedness. To blame the utility for lack of power in the aftermath of a storm of this magnitude is fairly ridiculous. All in, I'd say that a 1-2 week turnaround on restoring power is pretty goddamn good. Perhaps if folks bit the bullet and bought generators, many of which you can get for the price of your flatscreen, or your annual netflix memberships, this wouldn;t be such a burden.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mike Domlija

12:53 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

We have a generator, but the schools were still closed for ten days. It was dangerous to walk in the area due to downed power wires. Our business was virtually shut down for a week, since our associates and clients couldn't get to work. Forcing small business owners to buy generators, as this legislation would do, and in this way trying to compensate for the failing power grid is not the answer.

Right of Center

12:42 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

If only we could harness the hot-air-haymaking of weak minded politicians in an outage!

"apocalyptic" ? Please.

Require this, require that, who will end up paying the increased cost of all these requirements?

I know who.

Reply

Flood Plain

12:58 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Why not assume self-reliance for most houses. Buy your own stand-by generators fueled by natural gas where that fuel source is available, and liq propane in other areas. The cost of WHOLE HOUSE ELECTRIC stand-by is about $9 to $10,000 depending on house size.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tryclyde

1:26 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Oh, ONLY $9,000 - $10,000. So not only do I have to pay all this money to JCP&L to supply power to my house and fix any problems, but I should spend this money in addition?

Comment_arrow

Flood Plain

5:19 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Reply to tryclyde: YES! It is well known that when nature causes natural disasters, creature comforts will not be restored instantly. Be accountable for yourself for short run issues that might bother you a great deal.

Kurt

1:00 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

My wife and I drove around the sunday before the storm, and I was able to accurately predict more than a few of the trees on East Valley Brook which would come down and take out power lines. No, I am not psychic, but when they are still leaning on the wires since Irene hit, it wasn't too hard to guess. I am also just waiting for that 3 foot in diameter limb that crosses 517 between E. Valley Brook and the dog park to come down and take down the wires and potentially smush a car. Either bury the lines or cut down any tree capable of reaching the lines. Tax breaks either local, state, or federal to those burdened by the cost to do so. Or, don't do anything, and hold private property owners (via their insurance companies) liable if their tree they hold so dear damages the power lines, thus denying the public access to electricity. However, I have seen this rodeo before, so nothing will get done, and we'll all be complaining again in a few years.

Reply

Tryclyde

1:24 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I can't stand when these politicians get tough after the fact. All of it is posturing for re-election.

Reply
Comment_arrow

I am Spartacus

3:08 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Yes. They are allowed to pass along their costs for the cleanup just as they can pass along any other costs. Costs go up, rates generally go up. But they can't raise rates just because they feel like it.

Tammy

3:11 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

I find it ridiculous that they are considering increasing penalties. Does anybody think the money is going to come out of some CEO's pocket? No, it will come out of our pockets because they will just raise the rates to cover the cost of the penalties. I would suggest that the power company executives homes not have their power restored until everybody else's is restored but that's really not fair to their family members. I don't think there is really anything we can do to get them to improve their service.

Reply

Scondo

3:55 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

We can give everyone a back up generator cheaper than we can bury lines,

Reply

Joe videodummy

7:02 pm on Thursday, November 15, 2012

Smart Grid Technology using transistors and capacitors will replace the antiquated pole and wire systems one day. Think of it as WiFi Electric.
Not bad when you consider PSE &G produces roughly 5 million pounds of toxic chemicals that include manganese chromium, nickel componds, sulfuric and hydrochloric acid annually- something the EPA doesn't want anyone to know about.

Reply

Jacqueline Pisatowski

9:39 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

Rumana and Otoole are lawyers why haven't they filed a class action law suit to revoke the Wayne Franchise of JCP& L and compensate JCP&L's customers for their economic loss?

If the JCP&L stockholders had to compensate the aggrieved customers for lost food, lost work, temporary shelters...then the almighty dollar would help assure JCP&L's customers get appropriate level of emergency response.

Let’s see if the politicians we pay to represent sincerely want to protect us!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Z Jones

10:50 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

Hey Jacqueline, Joanie, and Joe,

Why doesn't Joe Bubba use his power at the BPU to get rid of JCP&L from Wayne? Or did he quit becasue he didn't get the Chief of Staff job?

Instead of canvassing for votes during a crisis, did you think about volunteering to help your neighbors by standing in line for 3 hours with a canister to get fuel for their generators? I did. You probably didn't since that requires real effort.

Oh and Jacqueline- legislators can't file a class action lawsuit against YOUR utility company, ONLY you and the town can. Before you file your petitions to run for office, get the facts and learn the law. Might help with getting votes, after you're done going door-to-door with Joanie and Joe Bubba.

Comment_arrow

Jack Q

11:30 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

Well stated @Z and @MIke S. The faux outrage is unbelievable. And Jackie, why don't you get Kristen Corrado to sue for you? She is still a "Strong" political ally of the Bubba's and the Murphy's, isn't she?

Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

1:08 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Dear: Z Jones, Jack Q and Mike S
or is it
Tom Buckley, Scott Rumana and Kevin Otoole?

You should consider helping your neighbors find a lawyer to help lead the charge. Our volunteer staff did the leg work and now the residents of Wayne need an attorney to file a petition.

All our volunteers have jobs. and also find time to be community servants without any elaborate titles or pay. Perhaps you and JCP&L cannot understand that we do not quit.

JCP&L needs to be held accountable.

Ask Scott Rumana about leaning what a legislator can and cannot do. He may reply that he learned the hard way!

Mike S

10:35 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

@Jacqueline Pisatowski,

You, Joanie and Bubba Jr went out to "check on your neighbors" bc as you said you are considering running for office next year. Now THAT'S the definition of pandering!

Before saying they weren't around to help, did you try calling them? I did, and they were immediately on the phone with JCP&L to find out when JCP&L would come to my neighborhood and get my power on.

You go pander to your neighbors for votes, and I'll talk to those who can actually do something to help!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

1:20 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Mike S:

If they were immediately on the phone with JCP&L are we learning about the benign affect they have as our State Representatives? After 1 day, 5 days, 9 days, 12 days were they still on hold? We need an electrical supplier that has an adequate emergency response capability.

If our Legislators were concerned they could have spent a full year working with JCP&L. They knew last year adjustments had to be made.

Why don't you stop criticizing volunteers and join our effort to solve the problem?

Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

1:47 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

You called our State Legislators and they immediately called JCP&L for us? After the first day, 4th day, 7th day, 10th day 12th day were they still on hold?

Have you helped explain the lack of respect JCP&L has for us or the benign nature of our State Legislators?

Please help our movement to hold JCP&L accountable rather than attacking volunteers.

Acton

10:49 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

Trim or remove all trees near power lines that pose substantial risk near the height of power lines. Why should a power company bear all the risk of what is on your property that poses a threat to its lines and to the community? Trees are wonderful, beautiful, and part of the character of the community, but there must be limits when the risks are so great.

Upgrade and reinforce power lines and utility poles.

Reply

janyne di biase

10:51 am on Friday, November 16, 2012

Also, diseased trees need to be replaced/trimmed (if possible).

Reply

Nose Wayne

12:48 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Florida has concrete telephone poles that are hurricane proof, not saying do every pole but the high voltage wire poles should be done.

Reply

chatham98

1:14 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

All things considered - things turned out for MOST people ok. The power companies did a heck of a job and misery has been held to a minimum. JCP&L and the teams they brought in (the guys on in my area were from Iowa) did a super job and I thank them very much. Could things have been done better and more efficiently? Yes, but planning for this event was poor by nearly everyone because no one expected the extent of the storm. I see way too much negative and emotional criticism on the blog here to help much in planning for the future and any similar events. I also see way too many "what about me" sort of comments. Do you really want to rely on political or municipal resources to survive a storm? You might as well expect to win the powerball! Paying more for such services in the future is no better than buying a power ball ticket - practically the same odds of winning whether I buy a ticket or not and a waste of your money or, at best, an entertainment expense.

It is probably impossible if not cost prohibitive to maintain such a disaster ready system. Come on - this sort of pain once or twice every 100 years - not bad. Stuff happens you know.

Reply

Robert Pignatello

1:38 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

It's too bad this is becoming the vehicle for political axes to be ground over an important life and safety issue. Seems to me that the work we should have done last year - after many of us lost power for more than a week - needs to be done this time without fail because while some may have written off last year as a once in a lifetime event, clearly that was wrong. In between the political rhetoric I've seen here there have been some useful ideas and thoughtful comments. But, Like too many issues I've seen addressed in Wayne, they get overshadowed and unduly influenced by the political posturing and motivations of political parties. What we desperately need in this town is a non partisan government that puts the people's interests and real solutions to real problems first and foremost above political party interests. If the people of Wayne want it enough it can happen.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jack Q

1:51 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

I agree Robert. The pandering by the Communications director of the Wayne Republican Party of the People is outrageous. While she says O'Toole is looking for votes, she is doing the same under the guise of a community organizer. It took the mayor to have to go to JCPL HQ to get things done in town. But the BPU is responsible for overseeing the utilities and they are also culpable. Personally, I think it is a disgrace that it took so long. It seemed that the biggest issue was tree removal around town, which should have been the easiest. You don't need bucket trucks to determine if lines are dead. Roads were blocked as well. It is astounding that in this great country, a town can be as crippled as it was and the utilities failed as they did. Everyone should sign the petition as a start, but heads must also roll at the BPU.

Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

2:25 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Jack Q,

I forgive you for attacking our volunteers. Perhaps you were blinded by your loyalty to those that enabled JCP&L.

Why don't you now something constructive to help us solve this power problem?.

Comment_arrow

Jack Q

2:43 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Jackie, I don't need your forgiveness. I have signed the petition, talked to my council person and the mayor so I think things will move in the right direction. Just because someone doesn't help your cadre of the Murphy Republican party, doesn't mean they aren't doing anything.

If you need a lawyer, I think Kristen Corrado can help you. Good luck in your future endeavors.

Comment_arrow

Jacqueline Pisatowski

3:56 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Jack Q you really should have just a little class and stop attacking a woman that is volunteering her time.

I feel a need to reply.

Peter Murphy crashed and burned right after he helped Scott Rumana become Mayor!

Many people do not realize that after Scott Rumana lost in a re-election attempt for Freeholder he became a politician looking for a place to hide!

He begged Peter Murphy to strip Judy Orsen's Republican Mayoral endorsement so that Rumana again could hold public office. Peter (not the sharpest tool in the shed) agreed and Rumana has been knifing him in the back ever since.

They deserve each other!

If Rumana is scared of anyone he tries to link them with Peter Murphy. It is the fastest way to get people's attention, but has not done a thing to build the Republican Party for years.

If you think I am close with either one of them you have another thing coming.

Funny though every time a politician needs 2000 votes from Totowa, Peter Murphy becomes popular!

The Wayne Republican Party for the PEOPLE was founded independent of any of these so called political big shots. We are just Wayne Residents that are tired of the tax-and-spend techniques that have eaten away at our incomes and put an undue burden on our families.

Why don't you identify yourself and pledge to volunteer with people that really want to make a difference?

Or are you really Scott Rumana?

Cj

2:36 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

I do think gas stations should have generators. How about the refinerys. Why were they shut down.
I think PsEG did a great job. I personally was without power for exactly one week and I honestly felt it could be longer. This storm was horrible. I give these guys credit and I feel for them as hard as they all worked. Give them some slack

Reply

Robert Pignatello

2:49 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Yes. I wrote to the BPU last year. Not even the courtesy of a response. There are some new commissioners who were appointed after last year's storms. They should hear from us too. I wish some enlightened legislator would introduce a bill that prohibits utilities from donating campaign cash to the political committees and parties that support the legislators who are supposed to be holding them accountable. Thousands of dollars from both JCP&L and PSE&G to both parties whose funds find their way to local candidates too. In general it's those kinds of ties and the conflicts they create that complicate real solutions and impede healthy debate a lot of the time. They handcuff the ability of elected leaders to act impartially because they are more beholden to their political interests than the public interest.

Reply

TCG

2:54 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Not sure what forcing private businesses to purchase generators has to do with holding power companies accountable. Power companies have no incentive to do better. And if you think imposing fines will work, look up the word lobbyist. There is not a chance in hell of legislation like this ever passing with any teeth to it. Where were all the politicians BEFORE the storm? We all saw this coming. The Governor was on TV for a week warning us to prepare. So why didn't federal, state and local politicians demand that generators be flown in BEFORE the storm? Why no inventory of gas stations without them? Why no gasolilne trucked in from the 46 states unaffected by the storm? Come on folks, the power companies and the politicans are in bed with each other and would NEVER do anything to harm the other's interests. This is all post-storm bluster that will do NOTHING to get power restored faster in when the next storm hits. The ONLY way to get the attention of the power companies is to pull their license. Wake me up when that happens.

Reply

Leslie

4:17 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

The money and effort are better spent on genuine perparedness plans. Who will be in charge when this stuff happens, where are the shelters, who reports street-by-street outages, where is the communication coming from, etc. My impression is that most people were able to endure 2 to 3 days without power; then it became bad. If we can get organized enough we don't need to bury lines or fine the companies.

Reply

MeerAveResident

6:58 pm on Friday, November 16, 2012

Generators at all gas stations? Not tested or oil changed for years at a time? A few weeks ago you were calling anything like this "Job-killing government regulation of the private businesses that built America." You can't have it both ways.

Reply

Warren

12:22 am on Saturday, November 17, 2012

Let's get the Rumana and O'Toole Hacks out of this discussion.

Reply

Liz Kril

1:13 pm on Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Is it possible for Montville to have its' own electric company like in Butler? Their electricity was restored in 2 days.

Reply

Leave a comment